How to Build a MemberPress Site: The DIY vs. Developer Guide

I get it. You’ve chosen MemberPress to build your online course or membership site, and now you’re standing at a critical crossroads. On one path, you’re the hero, building your entire site yourself from the ground up. On the other hand, you’re hiring a professional developer to bring your vision to life. So, which path is right for you?

This isn’t a simple question. In 2025, a successful membership platform is more than just a locked-down blog. It’s a strategic hub for content, community, and commerce. I’ve seen countless entrepreneurs face this same decision, and I’m here to help you navigate it. Let’s break down the pros and cons to help you make the best choice for your business.

Table of Contents:

1. Understanding Your MemberPress Project
2. Taking the DIY Route: Is It for Me?
3. Hiring a Developer: Is It Worth the Investment?
4. Factors I Consider Before Deciding
5. My Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Business

1. Understanding Your MemberPress Project

First, let me clarify what a modern MemberPress site really is. It’s not just about content protection anymore. Today, I see successful MemberPress sites that are:

• Robust Online Schools: I use MemberPress Courses to create structured learning paths with quizzes, assignments, and certificates.
• Tiered Membership Hubs: I offer multiple membership levels—like Basic, Pro, and VIP- each with different content and features.
• Thriving Paid Communities: I integrate MemberPress with plugins like BuddyBoss to build a private social network or forum for my members.
• Complex Subscriptions: I manage intricate recurring payments, custom user dashboards, and automated email sequences.

As you can see, building this kind of platform can go far beyond the basic setup.

2. Taking the DIY Route: Is It for Me?

I’m a big fan of the “do it yourself” approach, especially if you have the time and a basic understanding of WordPress.

Here’s why I might choose the DIY path:

• I Save a Ton of Money: This is a huge factor. I can build my site without paying a developer, which keeps my initial costs low.
• I Have Total Control: I can experiment with different plugins, change my design on a whim, and tweak every little detail exactly as I want it.
• I Learn Invaluable Skills: Building my own site taught me about the technical side of my business. This knowledge helps me troubleshoot issues down the road without needing outside help.

On the flip side, here’s why I might regret it:

• It’s a Major Time Commitment: What a developer can do in a few hours can take me days or even weeks. I’d be spending valuable time on setup instead of on creating my content or marketing my offer.
• I’m Limited by My Skills: If I need a custom feature or a unique design, I might hit a wall. My lack of coding knowledge could leave me with a generic-looking site that falls short of my vision.
• I Might Make Costly Mistakes: I’ve seen it happen. An incorrect setting can lead to a security vulnerability or a payment gateway that doesn’t work. These are frustrating and can damage my business.

The DIY route is best if: My project is straightforward, I’m on a tight budget, and I have a solid grasp of WordPress.

Are you ready to take on the DIY challenge?

Get MemberPress Today

 

3. Hiring a Developer: Is It Worth the Investment?

I often recommend hiring a developer when the stakes are high and my vision is complex.

Here’s why I would hire an expert:

• I Get Professional Expertise: A professional who specializes in MemberPress knows the platform inside and out. They can build my site faster, more securely, and with far fewer errors than I ever could.
• I Can Implement Anything: Want a unique member dashboard? Need a custom integration with a specific CRM? A developer can write the code to make it happen, making my site truly one-of-a-kind.
• I Save My Time and Sanity: My most valuable asset is my time. By outsourcing the build, I can focus on what I do best: creating great content, connecting with my audience, and growing my business.
• I get a Scalable and Secure Foundation: I know my site is built on a solid, secure, and optimized foundation that can handle growth without crashing. This is peace of mind I can’t put a price on.

On the other hand, here’s what I must consider:

• It’s an Investment: Good developers aren’t cheap. The cost is the biggest barrier for many people, but I view it as an investment in my business’s success.
• I Need to Find the Right Person: I have to do my research to find a developer with specific MemberPress experience. A general WordPress developer might not have the specialized knowledge I need.

Hiring a developer is best if: I have a complex vision, a tight launch timeline, and I want a professional, scalable site from day one.

Ready to turn your vision into a reality?

Build My Professional Site

 

4. Factors I Consider Before Deciding

When I face this choice, I ask myself these key questions:

• What is my skill level? Am I comfortable with things like hosting, DNS settings, and CSS? If not, a developer is probably my best bet.
• How complex is my project? Am I just locking a few blog posts, or am I building a full-fledged online school with quizzes, forums, and multiple membership levels? The more complex, the more I lean toward hiring help.
• What is my timeline? Do I need to launch in a week, or do I have a few months to learn and build? My deadline often determines whether I can take the time to do it myself.

My Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Business

I believe that the choice to hire a developer comes down to one thing: my time.
If my goal is to launch quickly, professionally, and without the stress of troubleshooting technical issues, then hiring a MemberPress developer is absolutely the right choice for me. The cost is an investment that I believe pays for itself in efficiency, security, and the freedom to focus on my core business.

However, if my project is small, my budget is limited, and I genuinely enjoy the learning process of building a site, then I can confidently take on the DIY challenge.

Ultimately, both paths can lead to a successful MemberPress site. The key is to be honest about my skills, my time, and my business goals. By making a thoughtful decision now, I can ensure my membership platform has a strong foundation for future growth.

Now, what will be your next step?